Wednesday, July 15, 2015

Week 9: Reflection on Mcluran videos and Jenkins quote


Jenkins (2010) states that for the past several decades media literacy advocates have called on schools to, "foster a critical understanding of media as one of the most powerful social, economic, political, and cultural institutions of our era" (p. 31).

This is an is is ainteresting quote on many levels.  In this course we are practicing the principals touted by Jenkins in this quote.  Among the readings for this week were the multimedia videos: Marshal Mcluran – an introduction by Tom Wolfe and The message is the massage, by Marshal Mcluran.  Among the media literacy advocates who have called on schools to use new media for learning includes the subject of these films, Marshal Mcluran.  Although these videos are many years old, they are a time capsule of a man who envisioned the possibilities and effects the internet would have on human civilization.  It is interesting to note that Mcluran states that the artists are usually ahead of academia in defining an era.  In this case, Mcluran is an academic who was ahead of his time.  He predicted many of the issues and significances of the internet age.

Mcluran was speaking mostly about television and movies which were the new media of his time.  It is interesting to note that Mcluran was not interested in television for his own interests, according to the Tom Wolfe video.  He was interested in watching his 6 children watch TV and use other new technologies at the time.  He observed the children watching TV, listening to the radio and doing their homework at the same time.  His conclusion was that education must be changed.  New media must be implemented into modern educational systems.  As stated in the opening quote, Mcluran was one of the leading advocates of learning and emerging technologies for decades.  He saw the educational potential of new media even before the advent of the internet.

Mcluran noted that the educational system was more relevant to 19th century reality.  There was a connection from what you were learning in school and real life outside of the classroom.  The advent of new media has changed reality. This new reality is very different from traditional classroom learning.  As noted before, many of Mcluran’s theories were written before the internet.  Now with the reality of social networks, communities and cultures supported by the World Wide Web, new media must be implemented into education.

Mcluran’s advocacy of new literacy and new media fits into Green’s model: operational, critical and cultural.  In the operational component, users are easily able to participate in participatory culture.  All that is needed is an internet connection and a media device.  Schools and libraries usually offer this connection for free.  Because it is so easy to get involved through the operational component, new media should be implemented into classrooms.  In the critical dimension, more multimedia and media rich text is being generated and used.  Instruction in the critical dimension must be provided to help guide the students through the research process.  The cultural dimension is multi layered in the World Wide Web.  New cultures are being generated online as I write this.  Because each information consumer can also be a creator of new internet content, instruction and guidance is needed in the cultural realm.

3 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Albert,
    I really enjoyed your discussion piece, primarily because I enjoyed McLuhan's work as well. IT was so interesting to hear him say that people do not live in the present, rather they "prefer" to live in the past where it is comfortable. It is so true... I loved how he referred to society still living in 'Bonanza Times', when the era had moved on to Suberbia.

    It was almost as if he was filled with so much information and he couldn't get it all out. However, he did say he was an investigator and an explorer. That was true with his statement of how he use to watch his kids watch TV and do work at the same time. He was always trying to understand how the messages effected society and the way of thinking. If you ask me, I found him to be a bit like Albert Einstein.

    As you mentioned in your post,TV and Radio were the mediums of his times.I found that McLuhan's statement that TV made the "westernman" turn inward to be a bit harsh. But after continuing to watch his video I realized that westerman did turn inward with TV. TV became the medium so that society was able to be on the same page and understand the communication with visual content as opposed to just listening to the radio. I wonder if McLuhan would think that the World Wide Web made men turn even more inward and effect us socially and emotionally, because I certainly do!

    Education seemed to be on his radar and for a man who said 50+ years ago that education needed to change the way it was being delivered, why do we still meet resistance in the classroom when it comes to students' using additional forms of technologies and such? There are still some teachers in the 20th century prohibiting smart phones from assisting students who are wired to multi task and learn at the same time. McLuhan saw the positive in this just by watching his own children learn.
    Amazing that this is still a topic up for debate. Our culture has been entrenched with outside mediums which carry messages in all types of fashions. It is up to us to decide how to incorporate them into society so that we can take advantage of them.. wouldn't you agree?
    Lori

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with the you that he was a bit like Albert Einstein. He was a forward thinker who predicted our behavior towards media 50 years ago - even before the internet. Being a part of this program we can be the people who are on the cutting edge of implementing his ideas into school curriculum.
      I also agree that present school curriculum is resistant to these changes. Maybe they are wary of the multiple messages. In their minds maybe there is a danger in not being in full control of the messages. You are correct. It is up to us to take control of the message and deliver it through the multimedia that the students are already comfortable using.

      Delete